Becerra Hasn’t Taken Office, but the California Teachers Association Already Has
The Teachers Union Gets the Keys
Well, that didn’t take long.
If anyone thought Xavier Becerra would show even a modicum of independence from California’s public employee unions (which a regular reader of this site would not), the governor-elect has pretty well dispelled that notion.
Last Friday, Becerra tapped Teri Holoman, the California Teachers Association’s associate executive director of governmental relations, to oversee appointments during his transition.
I’ve been involved in California politics for almost four decades. If you asked me to identify the single most destructive special interest in California politics over that period, I wouldn’t have to think about it. The California Teachers Association wins that distinction hands down.
Becerra could have brought in a senior CTA official to advise him on education policy or serve as his liaison to organized labor. Instead, he brought her in to help decide who will run virtually every aspect of his administration.
It’s hard to imagine a more consequential way for Becerra to demonstrate his subservience to California’s public employee unions.
One of the Most Powerful Jobs in Sacramento
Unless you’ve spent some time around state government, you probably aren’t familiar with the job of the governor’s appointments secretary. I’d argue that, especially at the outset of a new administration, it’s the most influential staff position after the chief of staff.
According to a 2023 legislative committee analysis, California has approximately 4,000 gubernatorial appointments. Only about 700 require confirmation by the State Senate.
We’re talking about the people who run our prisons, oversee our water supply, regulate businesses, administer healthcare programs, and spend billions of dollars on transportation. We’re talking about appointments to the Coastal Commission, the Air Resources Board, the High-Speed Rail Authority and the University of California Board of Regents.
You can tell a lot about how a governor intends to govern by looking at whom he appoints. The person overseeing appointments has enormous influence over whose applications receive serious consideration and whose end up in the proverbial circular file.
Holoman knows the drill. She previously served as a deputy appointments secretary under Gov. Jerry Brown. This year, Capitol Weekly ranked her ninth among California’s most influential unelected political figures.
Whether Holoman stays on as Becerra’s appointments secretary after the transition is anyone’s guess. But right now, when many of the most important personnel decisions of his entire governorship are being made, that’s essentially the job she’s doing.
California’s Most Destructive Special Interest
In July, I published an extensive piece examining how public employee unions built California’s most powerful political machine. Between 2000 and 2009 alone, the Fair Political Practices Commission found that the CTA and its affiliated committees spent more than $211 million on California politics — nearly twice as much as any other special interest.
With 310,000 members and more than 1,100 local chapters, the CTA’s political operation extends from the governor’s office down to the smallest school districts. As I’ve written about the destructive influence of public employee unions, government employees can effectively elect their own management. Guess who gets stuck with the bill?
I also recently outlined eight reasons why California’s public education monopoly is failing our children. The CTA is at the heart of much of what’s wrong with public education in California.
The union spent $26.4 million defeating a school voucher initiative in 2000. It has fought federal education reforms aimed at holding struggling schools accountable for academic performance and supported eliminating California’s high school exit examination. Yet no matter how poorly our students are doing, the CTA never seems to think we’re spending enough money.
During COVID, the CTA advocated closing every public school in California and subsequently pushed back against reopening. As a parent of two children who were school-aged during COVID, my disdain for the CTA isn’t entirely political.
The CTA has only one agenda front and center, and it isn’t the education of our children. It is higher pay, more benefits, and less accountability for its members.
The Realtors Get Their Own Seat
But wait, there’s more.
A day before announcing Holoman’s appointment, Becerra tapped Laiza Negrete, the California Association of Realtors’ vice president of political affairs, to oversee legislative affairs for his transition.
Negrete was a key player in the business-backed independent expenditure campaign that spent at least $36 million opposing billionaire Tom Steyer in the gubernatorial primary, much to Becerra’s benefit.
Ironically, the CTA had backed first Eric Swalwell and then Steyer in the primary. Apparently, when you’re as powerful as the CTA, you don’t even have to back the winning candidate.
The Realtors have a considerable financial stake in what happens in Sacramento, from property taxation and rent control to land use and the regulation of their own industry. I happen to agree with the Realtors on quite a few public policy issues. That’s beside the point.
The Realtors pay their political operatives to look out for their members. I expect the people working for the governor to look out for all Californians, including those who can’t afford to hire lobbyists in Sacramento.
Whatever happened to special-interest lobbyists having to go to the governor’s office to make their case?
So, Does It Matter?
I’ve lost count of the number of times over the years that I’ve watched good public policy in Sacramento go down in flames because Democratic politicians were unwilling to cross California’s public employee unions.
Now the most powerful of those unions will have a hand in staffing an entire administration.
Imagine for a moment that Steve Hilton had won the election and announced that a senior political operative from the oil industry would be overseeing appointments for his administration. The editorial pages of California’s major newspapers would be apoplectic.
California desperately needs a governor willing to take on the entrenched special interests that have made it so expensive to live here and have driven up the cost of a government that delivers increasingly poor results.
I am one of the millions of Californians who voted for Hilton. Obviously, our candidate fell short.
As for those Californians who voted for Xavier Becerra, they’re getting the government that the California Teachers Association has spent hundreds of millions of dollars to buy.
This article originally appeared on sodoesitmatter.com.
Jon Fleischman is a longtime political strategist in California. This column originally appeared on Jon’s Substack, So — Does it Matter?