Can Overloaded Community College Instructors Smoke Out Financial Aid Fraudsters?

Can Overloaded Community College Instructors Smoke Out Financial Aid Fraudsters?

Thien-Huong Ninh Villarreal, a community college professor, earned nearly $800,000 in 2024 according to public payroll records, CalMatters reported on November 12. This fall she is teaching 30 sociology, ethnic studies and business classes to about 1,100 students. Andrew Vanden Heuvel, another adjunct, teaches roughly 50 online classes and labs with as many as 1,000 students a semester. CalMatters identified at least 70 adjuncts who were paid by five or more community college districts, Cal State campuses or UC campuses in the same year.

Vanden Heuvel told CalMatters, “In its current form, I am not grading anything (by hand).” His quizzes are multiple choice and computer graded, and he usually grades written assignments with “an algorithm that only checks whether the work was submitted or not.”

By mass-producing education rather than engaging individually with students, these high-volume instructors may be poorly positioned to identify fraudulent enrollees, whose numbers have surged as scammers flood California’s community colleges with hundreds of thousands of fake applications.

Scammers took millions of dollars in federal and state aid from California’s community colleges in 2024 according to a January ABC7 investigation. The chancellor’s office estimated that the share of likely fake applicants rose from about 20 percent in 2021 to about 34 percent in its most recent data, CalMatters reported in April 2025.

ABC7 reported that, beyond vetting applications, colleges “are also counting on professors to catch names on their roster of students who never appear in class.” Beatriz Chaidez, chancellor of the San Jose-Evergreen Community College District, said most of the fraud she has seen occurs in self-paced online courses, according to ABC7. Reporting by Voice of San Diego, republished by the Hechinger Report, found that “asynchronous online courses tend to be the heaviest hit,” and that “classes with large sizes and shorter-term courses” are also hit hard. Vanden Heuvel’s roster of roughly 50 online classes and labs fits that profile.

A September 2021 memo issued by the chancellor’s office with the statewide Academic Senate and the association of chief instructional officers states that “faculty have the responsibility to verify active student engagement within their respective courses.” For online classes, it says instructors must “proactively engage with each student enrolled in an online course,” confirm engagement early and several times before the census date, and report students who do not participate. It recommends that faculty briefly review pre-census work for relevance, and it treats deliberately or knowingly failing to report inactive or fraudulent enrollments by the census deadline as engaging in or contributing to fraud.

Heather Dodge, a librarian teaching an online research course at Berkeley City College, asks each student to submit a video introduction in the first week, messages students who do not, and drops those who never respond. In a class that started with 35 students, four submitted written responses that read “like something ChatGPT would write.” Dodge tried to set up Zoom meetings with all four. Two never responded, and the Peralta Community College District removed the two who did meet with her.

At Southwestern College in Chula Vista, Elizabeth Smith spent the first two weeks of the term cutting 104 enrolled and waitlisted students in two online classes down to 15 she concluded were real. “I’m not teaching, I’m playing a cop now,” she said. CalMatters reported that dropping a student within the first week voids the enrollment, so the student cannot receive aid for the course, while removal after that point is harder.

These high-intensity approaches cannot scale up for adjuncts who are teaching 1000 students across multiple classes. And an instructor using completion-based grading cannot detect fake students who turn something (anything) in. An unnamed professor told ABC7 that “the scammers will sometimes answer an email or even complete a classroom assignment, just to keep the financial aid money flowing.”

The chancellor’s office fraud FAQ describes a category it calls “straw students,” first encountered as part of organized fraud rings, who attend classes, often online, “long enough to receive aid and disappear shortly thereafter.” A July 2026 alert from the Treasury Department’s Financial Crimes Enforcement Network defines straw students as complicit individuals who, for a fee, give fraudsters their personal identifying information, and it notes that fraudsters often exploit institutions with open admissions and online programs like California community colleges. Because complicit straw students may enroll using their genuine identities, identity-verification services such as ID.me cannot, by themselves, establish that applicants intend to study. Faculty who meaningfully assess student work and participation provide an additional line of defense against these schemes.

Chris Ferguson, an executive vice chancellor at the chancellor’s office, told CalMatters that holding multiple jobs becomes a problem when a “faculty member’s workload is preventing the required level of engagement, feedback, assessment, or student support,” and that “these requirements apply to every course, regardless of how many colleges or districts employ the instructor.” Adjuncts are generally limited to three classes per semester at a single district, but nothing prevents them from teaching at several districts at once.

The chancellor’s office should build a statewide record of each instructor’s combined sections and enrollment across districts, which would let districts see when a new assignment pushes an instructor’s total load past what Ferguson’s engagement standard can support. Districts should require documented, instructor-reviewed engagement in asynchronous sections before the census date, such as a video introduction or a first assignment graded by a person, rather than counting a completion check as attendance. And the State Auditor’s ghost-student fraud audit, which Assemblymember Blanca Rubio and Senators Rosilicie Ochoa Bogh and Roger Niello requested in May 2025 and which is due this fall, should compare fraud rates in sections taught by instructors with very large combined loads against fraud rates in other sections. Taxpayers paid Ninh Villarreal more than the system’s chancellor in 2024, and they are entitled to know whether loads of that size also weaken the colleges’ defenses against fraud.

Want more? Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox.

Thank you, we'll keep you informed!