Clinton Turns Her Back on School Choice While Trump Embraces It 

As Hillary Clinton cozies up to the teachers unions, Donald Trump seeks to vastly expand school choice opportunities. 

In November, 2015, Hillary Clinton gave a speech in South Carolina in which she abandoned her prior support for charter schools. Using language straight from the teachers union fact-free playbook, she claimed that charters “don’t take the hardest-to-teach kids, or, if they do, they don’t keep them.”

Fast forward to the National Education Association convention this past July. Mrs. Clinton made the terrible mistake of diverting from the teacher union party line by saying, “when schools get it right, whether they are traditional public schools or public charter schools, let’s figure out what’s working … and share it with schools across America.” This innocuous comment didn’t sit well with some of the unionistas in attendance, who made their displeasure known by booing the presidential candidate. Realizing that she strayed from union orthodoxy, Clinton regrouped by acknowledging that there are people on the outside who are pushing “for-profit charter schools on our kids. We will never stand for that. That is not acceptable.”

Later in her talk, she asserted, “There is no time for finger pointing, or arguing over who cares about kids more. It’s time to set one table and sit around it together – all of us – so we can work together to do what’s best for America’s children.” And that table, Clinton promised, will always have “a seat for educators.”

Two weeks later at the American Federation of Teachers convention, she went further, adding that she opposed “vouchers and for-profit schooling,” and repeated her pledge, “…you will always have a seat at the table.”

A seat for educators? No, not really. What she actually meant was a place for union bosses and their fellow travelers. Good to her word – at least in this case – that’s just what she did.

Last week, Mother Jones revealed just who is seated at Clinton’s table. (H/T Antonucci.) Participants include Lily Eskelsen García and Randi Weingarten, leaders of the two national teachers unions. They are joined by Carmel Martin and Catherine Brown, vice-presidents of the Center for American Progress, a leftist think tank that is financially supported by the teachers unions. Also seated is education reformer Chris Edley, president of the Opportunity Institute, a California-based think tank, whose board is a collection of Clinton cronies. And finally there is Richard Riley, who served as Bill Clinton’s education secretary and was the recipient of NEA’s Friend of Education Award.

Well, certainly no one can accuse Clinton of seeking out diverse viewpoints.

At the same time Clinton was doing the teachers unions’ bidding, Donald Trump did the opposite. In fact, he went all in for school choice. Speaking at Cleveland Arts and Social Sciences Academy, a charter school in Ohio, he promised, if elected, that he would redirect $20 billion in federal money to school-choice programs. Trump said he would make it a priority to give 11 million children living in poverty a choice of schools, including traditional public, charters, magnets and private schools. He proclaimed that parents should be able to walk their child to a school they choose to be at, adding that each state would develop its own formula for distributing the $20 billion block-grant money, but that the dollars must follow the student. Trump also had disparaging words for Common Core and promoted merit pay as a way to reward the best teachers.

Not surprisingly teacher union leaders were not exactly enthralled by The Donald’s vision and proceeded to blast his ideas, using tired and wrong-headed union anti-choice talking points. NEA president Lily Eskelsen García snapped: “His silver bullet approach does nothing to help the most-vulnerable students and ignores glaring opportunity gaps while taking away money from public schools to fill private-sector coffers. No matter what you call it, vouchers take dollars away from our public schools to fund private schools at taxpayers’ expense with little to no regard for our students.”

AFT president, Clinton BFF and reportedly her favorite candidate for Secretary of Education Randi Weingarten added, “Today’s speech on education repeats the same flawed ideology anti-public education zealots have been shilling for years. He shows his usual obeisance to the idea of making public education a market rather than a public trust, to blaming rather than respecting educators, and to ideas that have failed to help children everywhere they’ve been tried but instead, in their wake, have hurt kids by leaving public schools destabilized and their budgets drained.”

While I applaud Mr. Trump’s general vision, the devil will be in the details. Just how his plan will be implemented, including where the $20 billion for his block-grant plan will come from, is not clear. Also, Trump has been known to change his stance on various issues from week to week so we will have to see what transpires in the coming days. And the fact that he chose to give his speech at a failing charter school is typical of the gaffe-prone Republican nominee for president.

Kevin Chavous, a lifelong Democrat and education reformer, now finds himself in an odd position. After learning of Trump’s plan, he said, “While I do not support Donald Trump, his speech on school choice demonstrates that he is giving serious thought to education issues and I strongly challenge Hillary Clinton to do the same…I urge Hillary Clinton to show more openness and creativity when it comes to embracing school reform, choice and charter schools. So far Mrs. Clinton has largely been a representative of the interests of teachers’ unions and the status quo, which is in opposition to parents and students and will serve to be on the wrong side of history.”

Chavous is absolutely correct, but Hillary won’t change. She has jumped into bed with the teachers unions, which now own her. As such, if elected, she will indeed find herself on the wrong side of history – the children, whom she claims so fervently to care about, and their parents be damned.

Larry Sand, a former classroom teacher, is the president of the non-profit California Teachers Empowerment Network – a non-partisan, non-political group dedicated to providing teachers and the general public with reliable and balanced information about professional affiliations and positions on educational issues. The views presented here are strictly his own.

29 replies
  1. Avatar
    pokemon coin generator does it work says:

    Alice disse:Parabéns pelo aniversário ( desculpe o atraso pois não sabia ) e também por esse blog maravilhoso ! ! ! Tudo de bom Lina , pois você merece o melhor , por tantas alegrias que nos dá diariamente . Muitas felicidades ! Abraço a todas as mães do C.P. e como disse a Beth , as vovós também. Alice .

  2. Avatar says:

    Elárulom, mire jó ez:szárított alma-, citrom-, narancs-, grapefruit-, sütÅ‘tök-, céklaszeleteket lehet gyártani, de _nem_megevésre_! Ehh, dehogy! Díszítésre! Karácsonyi dekorációhoz, ajándékcsomagoláshoz leginkább.Én narancs, citrom és grapefruit (lehetÅ‘leg piros húsú) szárított szeleteket szoktam füzérnek felfűzni, és ablak elé lógatni. (Mondjuk eddig a fűtÅ‘testre raktam száradni. :))Nagyon szép a sütÅ‘tök, ha jó vékony a szelet, fodros lesz a széle – ja, ez sonkatökbÅ‘l klassz. A céklánál meg kis szerencsével a színárnyalatai is látszanak.

  3. Avatar says:

    Mijn ouders hadden er vroeger ook staan (er waren er zekere gele bij) maar nu ook al lang niet meer. Voor zover ik me herinner waren erbij die wel best lekker roken. Zelf heb ik ze niet, evenmin als dahlia’s en canna’s. Toch zijn het stuk voor stuk prachtige planten. Maar ze passen niet echt in onze wildere tuin. Ik denk er toch aan ze ergens in potten of bakken te ‘introduceren’, puur uit nostalgie.

  4. Avatar says:

    هادی می‌گه:سلام میلاد جونخیلی سایت باحالی درست کردی. دستت درد نکنهمن اتفاقا دنبال مطلبی راجب زیرنویس ها بودمسلام همه برسونهادی. ا.[]

  5. Avatar
    habbo hotel coin generator says:

      3 décembre 2012Coucou Cynthia,J’aime beaucoup tes vidéos et le fait que tu fasse des petits concours; moi je trouve ça super !!! Si je gagnais j’aimerais bien recevoir le « Vintage Green Stone Rose Flower Link Bracelets » car je trouve qu’il est élégant et assez original.Bisous

  6. Avatar says:

    value). I have 2 Kit-cat clocks, and don’t require more. But I would really like to get the earrings at the quoted price of $19.95 So please let me know if this is possible?? I do have an address in Washington State, just across the border in Lynnwood, north of Seattle. They can be sent there. I would like to hear from you if possible tomorrow, near 10am pacific time. As I’ll be out after that time, and not in on the weekend either. Phone # 604-298-1850. Thanks, Evelyn Dyck

  7. Avatar says:

    “It seems to remind people of phrenology which would also explain Steve why people are reticent.”I think the problem is that studies like this undermine the fundamental postulate of modern liberalism, which is that all people are born essentially the same.Liberals like to believe that a criminal is just an ordinary person who has easy access to guns. Or who went to schools that were underfunded. Or whatever.

  8. Avatar says:

    Great interview! Now I want to read her books. I love the reminder to pray that God would reveal what we should be emphasizing in our books. I’m all for letting themes and “lessons” grow organically rather than trying to insert them or form stories around them, but I hadn’t thought about how we should be seeking God’s help in understanding our stories’ themes. They are, in the end, very important!

  9. Avatar says:

    e ciò che dico io a questi amici, a me le ragazze non sembrano sbadate anzi, di loro ho un’opinione elevatissima, rimane però il fatto che io sono lo zio e loro i genitori.quando io ho sposato mia moglie, fior di dottori e avvocati coi soldi le stavno dietro mentre io ero uno studente, tra l’altro, senza soldi che lavorava per portate avanti la vita e gli studi, mi ricordo che il mio socero, quando mia moglie li ha detto che mi sposerà comunque, si è sentito male ed è finito all’ospedale.reza

  10. Avatar
    pokemon go coins hack root says:

    Well, Edward, I think that’s a bit of a stretch. Is this trying to remain distant and noncommittal (and cool)?You cannot discuss those ‘beliefs’ without tackling the existential stuff (even by default). And TCD does this quite a bit, if you ask me.

Leave a Reply

Want to join the discussion?
Feel free to contribute!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.