Matt Gush via Shutterstock
Firing the Hollister City Manager Didn’t Solve Its Problems

Mark Moses

Senior Fellow

Mark Moses
November 18, 2026

Firing the Hollister City Manager Didn’t Solve Its Problems

The City of Hollister is tripping over its own numbers. And the council still hasn’t decided what the city should be doing.

“Protecting public safety and maintaining essential municipal services remain the City’s highest priorities.”

That line is from a press release the City of Hollister issued on October 14, the day it sent layoff notices to about three dozen employees. The release didn’t say which services aren’t essential. Neither has the city council.

A week later, the city council fired the city manager who sent the notices. Five days after that, it withdrew the notices. The mayor says new ones may follow if the unions don’t give up enough in the contract negotiations now underway.

In 24 days, from October 2 to October 26, the council declared a financial emergency, approved an $18 million loan from fees developers paid for roads and parks, rescinded the emergency, fired its manager, and withdrew her layoffs.

Then, in an October 30 press release, the city said a review of its finances had found “material errors, omissions, and inconsistencies that call into question several assumptions underlying the emergency declaration.” It didn’t say which assumptions. The council declared the emergency after the city manager told it the city couldn’t make payroll. The release doesn’t mention payroll or cash.

I wrote “The City of Hollister Hasn’t Decided What It’s For” before the council fired City Manager Ana Cortez on October 21. The article credited Cortez and her finance director for ordering the bank accounts reconciled and hiring auditors to catch up on overdue audits. That credit stands. The council gave no reason for firing her. The backlash that preceded it was over the layoffs.

That piece was about the city council, and this one is too. A council has two levers for controlling costs: what the city does and how it does it. Using them begins with a standard for what the city is for. With such a standard, a council can judge which services belong and how to deliver them well at a cost the city can sustain. Without one, the city keeps doing what it has always done, much of it the way its unions prefer.

Hollister’s council never set that standard, so it never deliberately decided what the city should do or how it should do it. When the money ran short, it saw only two choices: spend the reserve or cut staff. It never tried a third: decide what the city is for and build the budget from there. In June, it chose to spend down the reserve. By October, the city said the reserve fund had no cash left, and it turned to cutting staff.

The layoffs would have cut people, not the work

In June, Cortez warned the council that the long-term goal was to cut 27 jobs. The council urged her to explore all other options first. Separation and retirement incentives offered in July didn’t save enough. On October 14, the notices went out.

Among those who got notices were a police captain, five water operators, an equipment mechanic, two accounting assistants, an accounting technician, two recreation coordinators, support staff at the airport and the fire department, and civilian police staff in records, evidence, and fleet maintenance. None of the reported notices went to firefighters. In June, Cortez had proposed 11 more fire positions to make that department “whole.”

The notices didn’t change what the city does or how it does it. The city would still have been expected to get arrest reports to the district attorney, keep the water running, and balance its checkbook, with fewer people to do it. Cut staff without changing how the work gets done, and services suffer.

The council is bargaining before deciding what the city should be doing

The police officers’ union and SEIU voted no confidence in Cortez. On October 19, after dozens of employees and residents spoke against the cuts, the council rescinded the financial emergency and asked the employees back from paid leave. Two days later, it fired Cortez on a 3-2 vote in closed session, named Airport Director Jeff Crechriou acting city manager, and told staff to meet with the unions and department heads on cutting costs. On October 26, after a closed session with its labor negotiators, it withdrew all the notices.

The mayor put it this way: “We need some very solid concessions from all of our unions.… The more concessions we can get, the fewer job losses we can anticipate moving forward.”

That makes it a choice between concessions or layoffs. Concessions make the same city cheaper for a while. Layoffs make the same city thinner. Either could close part of this year’s gap. The council can choose either without deciding what the city should really be doing or how it should be doing it.

Under state law, whether to provide a service is the council’s call, not a subject for bargaining. The council must bargain over the effects on employees, and sometimes over how the work is done, such as contracting it out.¹ That makes what the city does the council’s strongest lever.

The council needs numbers it can explain

In mid-October, city staff put this year’s general fund deficit at $6.9 million. On October 30, the city replaced a spreadsheet it had posted October 14. Its press release called the earlier version “an internal working draft released in error.” The new figures, preliminary and unaudited, show the general fund ending last year with $6.1 million and facing a $1 million deficit this year.

However, the two deficit calculations don’t measure the same thing. The mid-October figure compared $50.2 million in projected revenue with $57.1 million in spending. The new onei s “$56.1 million in Revenue & Beginning Fund Balance less $57.1 million in Expenditures.” It counts last year’s unaudited ending balance as money to spend this year. The release doesn’t explain the switch. Residents shouldn’t have to figure it out.

On October 2, Cortez told the council that at the end of September the general fund’s bank account held $178. To cover payroll and other bills, the council approved an $18 million loan: $11 million to the general fund and $7 million to the water fund.

One councilmember, who missed that meeting, has since said he would have questioned the figure: “The $178 statement. Crazy.” If the figure was wrong, the press release doesn’t say so. Nor does it say how much of the $6.1 million “surplus” is cash. A fund balance isn’t money in the bank. It can include money owed to the general fund that hasn’t come in. A cushion that isn’t cash can’t cover payroll.

The place to check is the balance sheet in the city’s audited financial statements. It shows what the general fund holds in cash and what it is owed. The most recent audited statements Hollister has released are for 2021-22. The auditor signed off on them in December 2025, almost three and a half years after the year ended. City policy calls for them within 180 days. Until the city catches up, no one, including the council, can confirm what the city has now or what cushion it will have going into next year.

The city reportedly plans to bring in an independent auditor to make sense of the numbers. But without current audited statements, an auditor has no solid starting point. And no auditor can fix bad budget assumptions or a budget update that residents can’t follow. Getting those right is management’s job. Making sure it happens is the council’s.

The acting city manager says his priority is to “evaluate and reduce” this year’s $57.1 million in general fund spending. Which spending to reduce is ultimately a decision about what the city does and how it does it. That decision belongs to the council, and the council has systematically avoided it.

The council should decide what the city is for before it hires the next manager

The council has said it will meet at least once a week to look for savings. There are two questions it has left open: What should the city be doing, and by what standard? And how should it be doing it? Such a discussion belongs in public, even if the bargaining doesn’t. Any plan to fix the city’s finances should follow from the answers.

The council should answer those questions before it hires a permanent city manager. In December, a new mayor and at least one new councilmember will take their seats. Meanwhile, the acting city manager can oversee the bank account reconciliation and financial audit catch-up. Only then will the city council have current, reliable financial information. The council doesn’t need audited statements to decide what the city is for. A manager can’t decide what the city is for. If the council doesn’t decide, the next manager will end up where Cortez did: numbers no one could confirm, no decision from the council, and nothing left to do but cut city staff.

Firing her didn’t resolve the city’s purpose, scope, or service delivery approach. Firing the next one won’t either.

Mark Moses is a senior fellow with the California Policy Center. He has 30 years of experience in local government administration and finance. His book, The Municipal Financial Crisis – A Framework for Understanding and Fixing Government Budgeting, was published by Palgrave Macmillan and is available from major online booksellers.

https://munifinanceguy.com/ X/Twitter: @MuniFinanceGuy

Want more? Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox.

Thank you, we'll keep you informed!