Retirement Security in America – A Tale of Two Contracts
Retirement Security in America – A Tale of Two Contracts
Two people walked into a bank, somewhere in California. Both individuals needed to prepare financially for their retirement. Both of them earned about $80,000 per year. The first individual, Mr. Jones, was presented by the banker with a contract called “Social Security.” The contract read as follows: For as long as you work, you will...
By Edward Ring
How Much Does Professionalism Cost?
How Much Does Professionalism Cost?
When discussing the sensitive subject of public employee compensation, there are several important dimensions that must be considered – can we afford it, is it appropriate and fair, how does it compare to the private sector (if comparisons can even be made), what are the additional costs for employer paid benefits, and how do we...
By Edward Ring
Public Sector Pension Plans Do Not Pass the "Smell Test"
Public Sector Pension Plans Do Not Pass the "Smell Test"
“Pew’s relationship with the Arnold Foundation does not pass the smell test,” said Meredith Williams, Denver-based executive director of the National Council on Teacher Retirement. – “Pension Funds Press Pew to Cut Arnold Foundation,” Philanthropy Today, March 4, 2014 If you’re looking for an example of how, increasingly, political debate in America is framed as...
By Edward Ring
Comparing CalSTRS Pensions to Social Security Retirement Benefits
Comparing CalSTRS Pensions to Social Security Retirement Benefits
Summary: This study compares Social Security retirement benefits to CalSTRS pension benefits and finds a significant disparity between the plans, despite the employee contributions being relatively similar. For example, the average CalSTRS participant retires at age 62, which is the current earliest age one may collect Social Security retirement benefits. At age 62, the average...
By Edward Ring
Pension Reform Comes to Ventura County
Pension Reform Comes to Ventura County
“401Ks carry no guarantee, and that’s the distinction between a defined contribution system and a defined benefit system.” – Rick Shimmel, executive director of the Ventura County Deputy Sheriffs’ Association, February 20, 2014, Fox News Soundbite Truer words were never spoken, Mr. Shimmel. But when the “guarantee” can’t be lowered to levels that are merely...
By Edward Ring
Pension Funds and the "Asset" Economy
Pension Funds and the "Asset" Economy
“You can’t build a society on artificially inflated asset values, because that accelerates the class division. Immigrants know that even if they work in a low-paying job in a hotel in Houston the chances they can save and buy a house are infinitely better than in California. If you want to have an asset based economy...
By Edward Ring
How Much Do CalPERS Retirees Really Make?
How Much Do CalPERS Retirees Really Make?
INTRODUCTION The pay and benefits of public employees is a discussion of increasing relevance to taxpayers. As noted in a CPPC study published earlier this month “How Much Do California’s State, City and County Workers Really Make?,” in California, personnel costs are estimated to consume 40% of total city budgets, 41% of the state budget...
By Edward Ring
How Does "Zero-point-Eight at Sixty-Eight" Sound for a Pension Plan?
How Does "Zero-point-Eight at Sixty-Eight" Sound for a Pension Plan?
The economy is picking up steam. State, city and county employees have willingly accepted millions upon millions of dollars in cuts to their pensions. California’s largest pension fund has recouped every single investment penny it lost from the Great Recession. So I thought perhaps California police officers, teachers, firefighters, and other public employees could finally exhale....
By Edward Ring
Transparency Website Shows True Cost of Unionized Government in California
Transparency Website Shows True Cost of Unionized Government in California
In light of the strong public policy supporting transparency in government, an individual’s expectation of privacy in a salary earned in public employment is significantly less than the privacy expectation regarding income earned in the private sector. – Excerpt from California Supreme Court Ruling, 8-27-2007, IFPTE v. Superior Court Today the California Public Policy Center...
By Edward Ring
How Much Do California's State, City and County Workers Really Make?
How Much Do California's State, City and County Workers Really Make?
INTRODUCTION What level of public employee pay and benefits are affordable and appropriate is a difficult but necessary discussion. And missing too often from this discussion is good data on just how much, on average, public employees are currently making. In California, the State controller has made available a database of public employee compensation, organized...
By Edward Ring
Forming a Bipartisan Consensus for Public Sector Union Reform
Forming a Bipartisan Consensus for Public Sector Union Reform
Across the United States there is an escalating political conflict over the role of labor unions in society. But it is inaccurate to characterize this conflict as one between Republicans and Democrats. There are members of both major political parties, as well as independents of widely diverse ideologies, who are concerned about civil liberties, the...
By Edward Ring
City of Redondo Beach Fights Unions – Full-time Firefighters Make $220,990 Total Compensation
City of Redondo Beach Fights Unions – Full-time Firefighters Make $220,990 Total Compensation
“If you say you can’t afford it, prove it. If you can’t prove it, pay up. We’re not being greedy here. It’s embarrassing how low we are paid compared to others. The average salary of a city employee in Redondo Beach is $47,000″ – President, Redondo Beach Fire Association, January 15, 2014, Daily Breeze article “Negotiations become...
By Edward Ring
City of Palo Alto Faces Strike – $139,907 Average Total Compensation Not Enough
City of Palo Alto Faces Strike – $139,907 Average Total Compensation Not Enough
“Although the city is recovering, we are and will continue to have difficulty attracting and retaining experienced and skilled employees if we don’t achieve a solution now.” Palo Alto City Employee and SEIU Local 521 Chapter Chair, Palo Alto Online, January 14, 2014 This refrain has been heard for over 20 years. It plays out...
By Edward Ring
Ushering in 2014 with Laws that Government Unions and Greens Adore
Ushering in 2014 with Laws that Government Unions and Greens Adore
California’s legislature passed, as usual, hundreds of laws that took effect on January 1st, but two of them are prime examples of how the Golden State has turned its governance over to an alliance of public sector unions, environmentalist extremists, and wealthy elites. Nowhere within this privileged clique is there any recognition of how difficult...
By Edward Ring