The City of Hollister Hasn’t Decided What It’s For

Mark Moses

Senior Fellow

Mark Moses
October 23, 2026

The City of Hollister Hasn’t Decided What It’s For

When the one-time money ran out, the city changed neither what it does nor how it does it.

“We cannot make payroll next week.”

That’s what Ana Cortez, Hollister’s city manager, told her council on October 2. A few days earlier, the city’s general fund bank account was down to $178. To make the October 6 payroll, the council declared a financial emergency and borrowed $18 million from the fees developers pay for roads and parks, to be repaid, somehow, by next June.1

Cortez, who joined the city in February, listed what went wrong: “We have not balanced our checkbook” (city bank accounts have not been reconciled), the “illegal transfer of special or restricted funds,” and the “use of one-time funds to increase the city’s expenses.”

Those failures are real, but they are symptoms. The first two hid how much spending had outpaced revenue. The third widened the gap. The City of Hollister never set limits on what it does, and a city without such limits can’t maintain administrative or fiscal discipline.

The good years masked the lack of a clear purpose

By Cortez’s assessment, the city has run at a deficit “for at least 10 years.” But midway through that decade, money came in faster than anticipated. In 2021-22, general fund revenue beat the budget by $9.75 million. On top of that came about $9.7 million in federal pandemic aid.

Rather than resolve the deficit, the revenue growth fueled a 65 percent increase in the general fund budget: from $31.7 million in 2021-22 to $52.1 million in 2024-25.2 Over the same period, the cost of typical local and state government purchases rose about 13 percent, and the city’s population grew only slightly. The 2023-24 budget added a fire captain, a veterinarian, and an economic development manager. Its budget message confirmed that these new positions “were possible through… the continued revenue growth in the region.” In those three years, funded positions rose by 30, to 222. While the number of police positions rose 12 percent, total police salaries and benefits rose 49 percent.

One-time money spent on employee pay rarely stays one-time. In April 2022, the council used pandemic aid to give every full-time employee $2,385 in hazard pay. Although these funds are gone, the increased employee expectations linger.

All this happened despite a written city policy that ongoing costs must be covered by ongoing revenues. But even sensible-sounding rules cannot ensure fiscal discipline when nothing limits what the city takes on.

The council made the fire department larger—and harder to shrink

When I advise a city on controlling costs, I emphasize two levers: what the city does and how it does it.

In 2013, the City of Hollister took over fire protection for unincorporated San Benito County and the City of San Juan Bautista. A city fire department that spreads the cost of fire stations and command staff over a larger territory can potentially achieve economies of scale. But such an arrangement assumes that the other agencies are aligned with the operational strategies, that those strategies are sound, and that those agencies pay for them.

The City of Hollister won the county contract by underbidding CAL FIRE while proposing three firefighters per engine. San Juan Bautista, which had its own volunteer department, signed a separate contract the same year. Hollister initially staffed the expanded fire operations with help from a temporary federal grant awarded in 2014. Grant funding continued until 2021-22, then ran out. Over the next three years, the fire budget rose by a third, from $12.1 million to $16.1 million.

The second lever is how the city delivers those services. Last year, with the fire services contracts up for renewal, the council brought the fire chief and the firefighters’ union president into its negotiations. The first item in the offer they helped write was a minimum of three firefighters on every engine. The offer asked San Benito County and the City of San Juan Bautista to pay a combined $6.5 million a year, the city’s own estimate of what serving them cost and $3.9 million more than they had been paying.3 Both said they couldn’t afford it. San Juan Bautista wanted three on its engine, but not at that price.

Essentially, everyone wanted to pay for two on an engine, but no one really had the political will to hold the line on staffing. The City of Hollister was the one to bow to the firefighters’ union, declaring that it would staff three on every engine. It was also the one with the financial risk. Under the two contracts, the other agencies pay fixed fees and require only two firefighters per engine. Service costs beyond those fees fall on Hollister’s general fund.

“It will cost money,” a Hollister councilmember had said, “but we’ll provide better service.”

Perhaps. But the firefighters’ labor contract didn’t require three.3 It left staffing to management, and management chose three. The fire chief told county supervisors that two per engine was feasible but said he would staff no engine with fewer than three “unless I’m directed otherwise.” Neither the former city manager nor the city council chose to intervene. By bringing the union in to help set the number, the council made it politically difficult to ever staff engines with two firefighters. The city chose a costlier, more rigid way of staffing its engines just when it most needed flexibility.

City leaders called it a revenue problem

When the money ran short, the city council bypassed both levers: it changed neither what the city did nor how it did it. The choice then came down to cutting staff or further depleting reserves. Cutting staff without using either lever is devastating to city services. In June, the council agreed to spend down its reserve.

The mayor said with admirable clarity, “There’s always going to be needs and wants on the expenditure side… We need to look for opportunities to increase revenue.” She said nothing about what the city would stop doing or start doing differently.

A city without a defined purpose creates its own financial instability. Every community want—and sometimes a labor union want—becomes a need, every need becomes a gap, and every gap becomes a city revenue problem. Budget scarcity becomes a way of life.

Residents paid for the gaps without ever being asked

Meanwhile, the general fund had been quietly subsidizing water rates. The council held water rates flat for most of a decade in which the water department had spent $26.4 million more than it collected. Once the water fund’s cash ran out, the general fund made up the difference. This sequence of events shifted a portion of the cost of water services from water customers to general taxpayers without so much as a notice in the mail.

In April, the council directed that $20.7 million of the rate subsidy be treated as a general fund loan to the water fund, to be repaid by water customers.

Of course, general fund spending had already well surpassed reliable, ongoing revenue. However, without the additional burden of covering the water funding shortfall, the general fund would not have run out of cash so abruptly. Such is how a city manages its way into insolvency.

Larger cities can make similarly poor choices yet retain enough cash to stay afloat. They have more maintenance to defer, more vehicle replacements to postpone, and larger self-insurance funds to pilfer. A city of 43,000 has fewer options. Once its pandemic money was spent, Hollister’s only legitimate cushion was its reserve, and no one knew for sure how big it was.

A higher tax ceiling won’t resolve what the city is for

The State of California caps local add-on sales taxes at a combined 2 percent above the 7.25 percent statewide rate. Hollister is already at the maximum 9.25 percent. Increasing its add-on sales tax requires a state law naming the city as an exception. On October 2, the city council voted to ask the State Legislature for one.

If allowed by the state and approved by voters, a new tax would bring in more money. But Hollister has already shown what it does with more money. So has Apple Valley, where voters approved a new sales tax in 2024; the additional $11 million a year solved nothing.

What has changed for the better in Hollister is the management, and it deserves credit. Cortez and her finance director have ordered past years’ bank statements reconciled, hired auditors to catch up on audits that stopped after 2021-22, and told the council—in public, no less—what went wrong. Cortez asked the council for a budget framework in April and has offered the start of one: “Municipal governments are about three things: police, fire, potholes.”

The city council has to step up. “Police, fire, potholes” doesn’t settle whether Hollister should provide fire service to the county and San Juan Bautista, or how many firefighters ride each engine. Without those answers, the same three words can justify more spending as easily as less. In June, Cortez proposed 11 more fire positions to make the department “whole.” Before it asks voters to consider a higher tax, the council owes residents clear answers to two questions: What will the city stop doing? And how will it change the way it does what it keeps doing?

Hollister’s finance staff are balancing the checkbook. Only the council can decide what the checks are for.

Mark Moses is a senior fellow with the California Policy Center. He has 30 years of experience in local government administration and finance. His book, The Municipal Financial Crisis – A Framework for Understanding and Fixing Government Budgeting, was published by Palgrave Macmillan and is available from major online booksellers.

https://munifinanceguy.com/ X/Twitter: @MuniFinanceGuy

Notes

1. Of the $18 million, $11 million went to the general fund and $7 million to the water fund, to help cover payroll and operating costs.

2. This account is built from the public record: the city’s adopted budgets, including the fiscal policies in its 2024-25 budget; its audited financial statements for 2021-22, the most recent available; the firefighters’ labor agreement; council staff reports; and reporting by BenitoLink, SanBenito.com and KSBW. Figures after 2021-22 are unaudited. The general fund comparison uses adopted budgets for both years. The fire comparison counts all funding sources, including $790,000 in federal grant money in 2021-22, and runs from that year’s actual spending to the 2024-25 adopted budget. The price comparison uses the U.S. Bureau of Economic Analysis price index for state and local government purchases.

3. The city’s $6.5 million estimate allocated the fire department’s net cost by where calls came from. Fixed fees: the county $3.38 million, rising 3 percent a year to $3.8 million in 2028-29; the City of San Juan Bautista $418,279, rising 11 percent a year. Both contracts set a minimum of two firefighters at the stations serving the other agencies. The contracts can be ended only for nonpayment, or by mutual agreement if a fire district forms. The 2024-25 firefighters’ agreement, Article 13, calls for three “whenever possible” and “does not establish Mandatory Minimum Staffing Levels.”

Want more? Get stories like this delivered straight to your inbox.

Thank you, we'll keep you informed!