The Fuzzy Math Behind Prop 40’s Alleged Healthcare Cuts
Besides making billionaires pay their “fair share”, the case for Proposition 40 revolves around offsetting “catastrophic” federal Medi-Cal cuts. These cuts will likely be reversed by an incoming Democratic Congress, but, regardless, the expected cuts are not as catastrophic as Prop 40 advocates make them out to be.
Last September, the campaign that later qualified Proposition 40 for the ballot announced that California faced approximately $100 billion in federal healthcare funding cuts over the next five years. I haven’t seem a breakdown of the expected $100 billion loss, but it was undoubtedly built on assumptions that will not pan out.
Exaggerated projections of how many Californians will be “kicked off” Medi-Cal by so-called work requirements illustrate the fuzzy math. The initiative’s findings warn that federal cuts threaten to end coverage for millions of low-income Californians. A California Budget & Policy Center fact sheet posted by the Assembly Health Committee in January claimed that about 3 million adults could lose Medi-Cal from the work requirement alone. It described the rule as requiring adults to document at least 80 hours a month of work, job search or job training. By May, the Department of Health Care Services had cut its own projection of work requirement losses to 1.06 million by 2029-30, about a third of that figure.
The requirement is far easier to meet than that fact sheet suggested. On September 11, DHCS sent counties the notice it is mailing to Medi-Cal members. According to the notice, an expansion adult satisfies the rule by having income of at least $580 from any source in any single month since the last renewal (based on 80 hours of work at the federal minimum wage). Renewals will occur every six months. California’s minimum wage rises to $17.40 an hour on January 1, so 34 hours of minimum-wage work in one month keeps a beneficiary covered for half a year.
The income does not have to come from work. DHCS’s county guidance lists unemployment benefits, State Disability Insurance, retirement income and dividends as countable income. So it may not be necessary to even work those 34 hours in one month.
Beneficiaries with no income have other options. The notice says 80 hours of work, volunteering, community service or job training in any single month since the last renewal satisfies the rule. So does attending school at least part time. As long as the beneficiary spends a total of 80 hours on these activities in one month of the last six, he or she continues to qualify.
Advocacy groups and health plans will help beneficiaries rack up those hours. Los Angeles County’s Department of Public Social Services is working with the nonprofit intermediary Community Partners to recruit nonprofits as volunteer worksites for people facing work requirements. L.A. Care Health Plan lists work, volunteer and educational opportunities for members subject to the rule. The DHCS notice tells members that the Legislature has funded new resources and promises lists of local job, volunteer and school opportunities before the end of the year.
There are also broad exemptions from meeting even these very limited criteria. The notice excuses American Indians, parents of children 13 or younger, caregivers for people with disabilities, people with a serious mental health condition, and anyone who overuses or misuses drugs or alcohol. DHCS projects that 2.2 million of the 4.8 million enrollees in the affected group will qualify for an exemption.
Through 2027, federal rules allow states to accept a beneficiary’s sworn self-attestation of compliance or of most health exemptions when data sources cannot verify them. DHCS’s county guidance already provides for accepting self-attestation of exemptions such as medical frailty. A beneficiary willing to sign a false statement can keep coverage.
As I wrote last week, the state and counties are already raising taxes to fill some of federal funds Medi-Cal may lose due to HR1. And now we see that these losses have been inflated. When considering a vote on Proposition 40, remember that the Medi-Cal funding emergency might not really be an emergency after all.